A Real Mixed ‘Fruit’ Festive Cake Tasting
Mince Pies in 2015, Christmas Puddings 2016 and for 2017 we put the ‘Iced Fruit Bar’ to the blind tasting test. An Iced fruit bar is a big slice of Christmas cake topped with icing. We recruited taste testers from Citizens Advice Jersey, Trading Standards, the Channel Island Competition and Regulatory Authorities and 4insight. It should be noted that our tester from Trading Standards was an entrant to the Great British Bake off 2015 – he knows his fruit cakes. Our 5 testers each tester could award a maximum of 25 points per cake, covering aroma, fruit content, texture, appearance and richness; our testers scored the M&S’s Classic Recipe Top Iced Bar Christmas Cake as their favourite but a very close challenger was Tesco’s Iced Rich Fruit Cake
Detailed below are the scores from the ‘blind’ tasting. Now it is your turn to see if you agree with our testers!
Please note that we had to carry out our taste testing late November to meet our publication schedule; we are mindful that the full selection of Christmas cakes may not have been available at this time.
A few of our tasters’ comments; ‘lovely rich spice and alcohol aroma’ ‘almond taste throughout’ ‘a little dry and crumbly’ ‘tasty’ ‘high fruit comment’ ’loved the cherries’ ‘not much marzipan’